Sunday, December 22, 2024

Gareth Barry to Manchester City – money or ambition?

Hopefully, anyone who reads this site occasionally or regularly will realise that I love the game of football. I get very upset by the sniping, criticism and cynicism that is displayed towards the game by the media and I get very upset with the constant ridiculing of players as thick thugs who are only in the game for the money.

Supportive

It is because of efforts I make to be supportive of the game and the players that I am left feeling let down by players who fulfil the stereotypes they are so often given.

Nobody has ever called England midfielder Gareth Barry thick as far as I’m aware and he certainly seems to be a very long way away from being a thug. It is when it comes to the third part of the stereotype that we begin to have problems with Barry. Only in it for the money?

It is difficult to criticise a player for agreeing a move that will guarantee him around £25million over five years. Signing for Manchester City has set Barry up for life and after serving twelve years at Aston Villa, his only professional club, at the age of twenty-eight, many people will simply say, “good luck to him.”

In many ways I join those well wishers, but deep down inside I am really disappointed that he has made the move.

Partnership

Just last week Steve Gerrard was talking about forming a club partnership with Barry at Liverpool to go alongside their partnership for England. It was widely expected that Rafa Benitez would make another attempt to take Barry to Anfield after the failure of their very public bid last Summer. At that time it was very clear that Barry wanted to go to Liverpool and he has made no secret of his desire to play Champions League football.

Even if the Liverpool move didn’t come off there was talk about interest from Arsene Wenger. This could have been another avenue down which Gareth Barry could get the Champions League football that he says is so important to him.

The simple fact is, of course, that Manchester City did not even qualify for next season’s Europa League. Barry’s old club Aston Villa will be competing in Europe but his new club won’t. Barry talked of a fear of going stale at Villa but had previously only considered a move to one of the top four teams.

Ambitious

So what changed his mind? Was it the ambitious plans that City’s owners have and the fact that they can compete for the signatures of the world’s top players? Was it the fact that City will be aiming for qualification to the Champions League next season or the season after at the latest? Was it, as he says, simply the desire for a new challenge? Or was it the £130,000 per week that persuaded him?

I was very happy when Kaka turned down the ridiculous offer he was made by Manchester City and decided to stay at Milan. It sent a great message across the world of football that it isn’t easy just to buy your way to success. Players are looking for career goals and objectives more than they are looking at what they earn.

Now I worry that Gareth Barry is the first of many top players that might make their way to Eastlands this Summer and City might indeed be able to buy some success for their fans. I’m sure City fans won’t be complaining but it can’t be good for football.

Justify

Barry had made his career goal very clear and he struggles to justify his move on the basis that Champions League football may come in due course. He is twenty-eight years old and whilst time is not exactly running out, it is certainly not on his side.

I would have more respect for Barry if he simply asked, “wouldn’t you accept a job doing what you love doing and getting paid £25million for it over five years?”

I know my answer would be yes. I just wish that clubs couldn’t pay that sort of silly money.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Graham Fisher


SHARE OR COMMENT ON THIS ARTICLE

WE RECOMMEND

  • Stephen Ledley

    0 0

    i think barry should go to liverpool
    not city
    barry just want money

  • Brad

    0 0

    You’re very narrow minded POOPOP.

  • POOPOP

    0 0

    It is cuz of the monay, gizzzzzzzzzzz. Barry is greedy.

  • Brad

    0 0

    Actually, Cynical Blue, I think City did pretty good this season.

  • CynicalBlue

    0 0

    Thank you Graham for your humility-and thank you for your honesty at admitting to being a Watford supporter!

    But ask yourself another question-if an incredibly rich (not Elton rich but someone who would ‘make Elton look like a backing singer’ type rich) offered to back your team and shoot for the stars, how would you feel?

    Would you be giddy with excitement and thrilled to go on a roller-coaster of adventure or would you be condeming Watford for ruining the game/selling out/buying success (delete as applicable)

    The big 4 are the big 4 ONLY because they get the most money year in and year out. Not for history/fans/silverware or loyalty. The same applies for every top team in every country. It’s a never-ending cycle-the ONLY way it can be broken is if a private individual invests a substantial fortune into a club and even then it’s not guaranteed since they have had their own way for up to 20 years and built great squads.

    City should be applauded by all (non big 4) fans not castigated,

  • Brad

    0 0

    It is probably for the money.
    Wait it could be the guys ambition….
    Oh i dont know!
    Ah well, I read someun sayin that Man U and Liverpool are near bankrupt………
    It may be off topic but i hope they dont file for it or we may not get to see the Premierships Big Two play anymore!

  • Graham Fisher

    0 0

    Thanks for all your comments. To answer a few points:

    I took the wages figure from the usually reliable BBC.

    I made it quite clear that I would take the money. I’m not criticising him for that.

    The team in the big four I support is……Watford! 🙂

  • William Boland

    0 0

    Really you should check your facts before you start writing such drivel. 95% of reports, including sky sports which i would think may be a bit more reliable than your good self, have it that he is earning £90,000 a week. In fact you are the first person to have it as high as £130,000, the previous high i saw was £110,000 from the daily mail. Villa were actually offering him £80,000 a week, so really he is earning an extra £5,000 a week after tax, hardly the actions of an immoral individual.

    And i am sick to death of people being criticised for snubbing the ‘big four’. What do you want, the same four teams competing for the premiership every year. How is another club supposed to break that monopoly without some of the better players being willing to join them.

  • Bart

    0 0

    Perhaps you would want the cosy cartel that is the SKY Four to continue to dominate our game unchallenged? Perhaps you think that they haven’t flexed their financial muscles? Didn’t notice such bleating when they were spending vast fortunes. Where is the criticism of the likes of Real Madrid in bidding for Kaka?
    What about the fact that Manu ,and Liverpool are on the verge of bankruptcy, are you going to whinge on about that?
    To summarise ,this is a poor quality , tired old repitition of the worst kind of trash which the Fleet Street jouralists who can’t see past the SKY four knock out week in week out. They don’t have the knowledge of what goes on outside the cartel and are quite happy to knock anyone who tries to improve. Would suggest you do your homework in the future and check your facts as to what is going on at Clubs like City, the academy , the community projects, the ever clsoer interaction with the supporters and their desire to break through to the top.
    You should be applauding the Club

  • CynicalBlue

    0 0

    Oh gosh-another; “Oooh, I’m so angry I could stamp my foot blog post”.

    Any chance of some facts to get in the way?
    1) Barry is not a Villa youth protegee-they bought him from Brighton.
    2) He spent 12 years with the same employer-how many of your readers can say the same. I can’t. I get restless after about 5 1/2, why should he be different?
    3) Last year he made noises about joining a CL side – NOT this year. Perhaps that was to soften the blow to the Villa fans who he seems to have great respect for.
    4) Last year. Liverpool made a bid. NOTHING this year-nor Arsenal or any of the ‘big’ sides.
    5) So City aren’t in Europe. Remember Villa’s European adventure? Pick a team of kids and Notrites and go out. It was the only bloody trophy they could have won! Instead they followed a dream to be in the CL…Good work Mr O’Neill
    6) After Jan-how many matches did Villa win? 2 wasn’t it? And one of those was against the worst Newcastle side I have ever seen! They are not a team that is going anywhere. Great Chairman, competent manager, great fans but route one football.

    If someone offered to double your wages to change job would you? Why is that different for a footballer? The only loyalty in football is with the fans.

    BTW, which ‘big 4’ side are you a fan of?

  • DarkDefender

    0 0

    Well talkin about buying, Blackburn did it in 90s, chelski did few years back, real does it all the time with the backin of spanish goverment in favor of taxes, top teams does it all the time liverpool 52 players in 4 years totaling £190million and united 17 players since 2004, totaling 184,000,000 so dont talk about buyin your success. Its hypocryte and only shows how big clubs dont want new kid on the blcok to mess up their game I think its refressing that new clubs emerge to at least try to compete with big boys…

  • DarkDefender

    0 0

    Well talkin about buying, Blackburn did it in 90s, chelski did few years back, real does it all the time with the backin of spanish goverment in favor of taxes, top teams does it all the time liverpool 52 players in 4 years totaling £190million and united 17 players since 2004, totaling 184,000,000 so dont talk about buyin your success. Its hypocryte and only shows how big clubs dont want new kid on the blcok to mess up their game I think its refressing that new clubs emerge to at least try to compete with big boys…

  • CynicalBlue

    0 0

    Oh gosh-another; “Oooh, I’m so angry I could stamp my foot blog post”.

    Any chance of some facts to get in the way?
    1) Barry is not a Villa youth protegee-they bought him from Brighton.
    2) He spent 12 years with the same employer-how many of your readers can say the same. I can’t. I get restless after about 5 1/2, why should he be different?
    3) Last year he made noises about joining a CL side – NOT this year. Perhaps that was to soften the blow to the Villa fans who he seems to have great respect for.
    4) Last year. Liverpool made a bid. NOTHING this year-nor Arsenal or any of the ‘big’ sides.
    5) So City aren’t in Europe. Remember Villa’s European adventure? Pick a team of kids and Notrites and go out. It was the only bloody trophy they could have won! Instead they followed a dream to be in the CL…Good work Mr O’Neill
    6) After Jan-how many matches did Villa win? 2 wasn’t it? And one of those was against the worst Newcastle side I have ever seen! They are not a team that is going anywhere. Great Chairman, competent manager, great fans but route one football.

    If someone offered to double your wages to change job would you? Why is that different for a footballer? The only loyalty in football is with the fans.

    BTW, which ‘big 4’ side are you a fan of?

  • Bart

    0 0

    Perhaps you would want the cosy cartel that is the SKY Four to continue to dominate our game unchallenged? Perhaps you think that they haven’t flexed their financial muscles? Didn’t notice such bleating when they were spending vast fortunes. Where is the criticism of the likes of Real Madrid in bidding for Kaka?
    What about the fact that Manu ,and Liverpool are on the verge of bankruptcy, are you going to whinge on about that?
    To summarise ,this is a poor quality , tired old repitition of the worst kind of trash which the Fleet Street jouralists who can’t see past the SKY four knock out week in week out. They don’t have the knowledge of what goes on outside the cartel and are quite happy to knock anyone who tries to improve. Would suggest you do your homework in the future and check your facts as to what is going on at Clubs like City, the academy , the community projects, the ever clsoer interaction with the supporters and their desire to break through to the top.
    You should be applauding the Club

  • William Boland

    0 0

    Really you should check your facts before you start writing such drivel. 95% of reports, including sky sports which i would think may be a bit more reliable than your good self, have it that he is earning £90,000 a week. In fact you are the first person to have it as high as £130,000, the previous high i saw was £110,000 from the daily mail. Villa were actually offering him £80,000 a week, so really he is earning an extra £5,000 a week after tax, hardly the actions of an immoral individual.

    And i am sick to death of people being criticised for snubbing the ‘big four’. What do you want, the same four teams competing for the premiership every year. How is another club supposed to break that monopoly without some of the better players being willing to join them.

  • Graham Fisher

    0 0

    Thanks for all your comments. To answer a few points:

    I took the wages figure from the usually reliable BBC.

    I made it quite clear that I would take the money. I’m not criticising him for that.

    The team in the big four I support is……Watford! 🙂

  • Brad

    0 0

    It is probably for the money.
    Wait it could be the guys ambition….
    Oh i dont know!
    Ah well, I read someun sayin that Man U and Liverpool are near bankrupt………
    It may be off topic but i hope they dont file for it or we may not get to see the Premierships Big Two play anymore!

  • CynicalBlue

    0 0

    Thank you Graham for your humility-and thank you for your honesty at admitting to being a Watford supporter!

    But ask yourself another question-if an incredibly rich (not Elton rich but someone who would ‘make Elton look like a backing singer’ type rich) offered to back your team and shoot for the stars, how would you feel?

    Would you be giddy with excitement and thrilled to go on a roller-coaster of adventure or would you be condeming Watford for ruining the game/selling out/buying success (delete as applicable)

    The big 4 are the big 4 ONLY because they get the most money year in and year out. Not for history/fans/silverware or loyalty. The same applies for every top team in every country. It’s a never-ending cycle-the ONLY way it can be broken is if a private individual invests a substantial fortune into a club and even then it’s not guaranteed since they have had their own way for up to 20 years and built great squads.

    City should be applauded by all (non big 4) fans not castigated,

  • Brad

    0 0

    Actually, Cynical Blue, I think City did pretty good this season.

  • POOPOP

    0 0

    It is cuz of the monay, gizzzzzzzzzzz. Barry is greedy.

  • Brad

    0 0

    You’re very narrow minded POOPOP.

  • Stephen Ledley

    0 0

    i think barry should go to liverpool
    not city
    barry just want money

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This field is required *

Join the conversation!

or Register

Live Scores

advertisement

Betting Guide Advertisement

advertisement

Become a Writer
More More
Top