Wednesday, November 20, 2024

How long will FIFA bury their head in the sand over video technology?

The governing body of the biggest sport in the world seem to be completely clueless.

Fifa are allegedly a multi-billion pound organisation who is supposed to look after the interests of football but at times they seem out of their depth.

The video technology debate is the perfect example of their ineffectiveness.

Blatter

Fifa president Sepp Blatter seems to go from one debacle to another. He is completely against the idea of video technology in the game.

Surely even MR Blatter must now think about video technology being brought into the game, after two amazing mistakes in yesterday’s last 16 World Cup clashes.

It was not hard to spot that Frank Lampard’s effort went over the line. My grandmother knew it was over the line and she is partially-sighted! She even suggested that the linesman needs to get down the opticians first thing on Monday morning.

Then there was the ridiculous Argentina goal that should have been disallowed against the Mexicans. It was obvious to everybody in the ground that Carlos Tevez was offside. I’m not surprised the Mexican players were surrounding the officials.

Both incidents could have had a big say in the way with which the games were going. England were losing 2-1 at the time of Lampard’s ‘Ghost Goal’ and Mexico were holding the Argentinian’s at 0-0 and had just struck the post.

Important

These human errors can be very costly for teams. The decisions may not have really changed the outcomes of the England or Mexico games but they could have changed the course of the World Cup.

Human Error

Football has always had to deal with the human error factor. Some say it adds to the excitement of football. However I would rather watch a game which is won by right decisions. I would prefer the game be stopped for 10 seconds while the correct decision is made.

They have video technology in nearly every other sport and it doesn’t spoil those sports. It will take a short amount of time to bring the game back. It won’t slow the game down to a great degree and we will be getting fair and correct results.

Bias

I am not just broaching this issue because England was involved in a controversial incident either. The reason we need to address this issue is because the crazy decisions that are being made are turning our game into a laughing stock.

Cost

Blatter’s reason for ruling out video technology is the cost of installing technology. It wouldn’t cost a great deal of money for the technology to be introduced. The fourth official can already see the action on screens in most dugouts across Europe’s top leagues.

Even the big screen at some grounds show incidents just after they have taken place (just like the big screen did in the Argentina-Mexico game). Would it really be that costly for the referee and linesman to see such important events again? I doubt it.

It’s in the interests of football for the governing body to final bring in the needed technology. Football is a billion-dollar industry and for silly officiating mistakes to have such a big say in the game is quite frankly astounding.

2010

We are now in the year 2010 and football is stuck in the 1890’s. It’s time our sport evolved into a sport for the 21st century. We have the capabilities to make correct decisions. So why are Blatter and co. being so stubborn? I’m not sure but surely it is time for the organisation to reconsider their thinking.

Should video technology be brought into football?

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

David Nugent


David is a freelance football writer with nearly a decade of experience writing about the beautiful game. The experienced writer has written for over a dozen websites and also an international soccer magazine offline.
Arguably his best work has come as an editorial writer for Soccernews, sharing his good, bad and ugly opinions on the world’s favourite sport. During David’s writing career he has written editorials, betting previews, match previews, banter, news and opinion pieces.

SHARE OR COMMENT ON THIS ARTICLE

WE RECOMMEND

  • Dan

    0 0

    FIFA must start using video footage or other technological solutions for goal line decisons. It is unacceptable to have errors made on goal decisions when it can be so easily avoided. Join the Facebook group “Come on FIFA, use the video footage for crying out loud!”

  • Jon

    0 0

    Quite right mate, I have always been for video technology in the game.

    I understand FIFAs view about the cost, thats fine, so lets have it for the top divisions where the money is, and the important competitions like world cups!

    Sepp Blahblah says it will ruin the pace of the game.. ok, but we already have long stoppages if someone is suspected of bad behaviour, while the referee consults his officials. The 4th referee even, as you say, has a tv which he can check on and give the referee advice with. This can so so easily be used for goal line decisions. After all, its goals that make the game, lets get it right and get fair results. It doesn’t take long, and can even add to the spectacle while everyone waits for 10 seconds for the result of the video review.

    It works in cricket, and in rugby which isn’t exactly a game played at half pace either. Its just a shame that for England that the referee and linesman were the only people in the world to think the ball didn’t cross the line, and to think that Tevez opener was a legal goal against Mexico.

    Human error is part of the game, but I’d rather leave it to the players to make mistakes.

  • Jon

    0 0

    Quite right mate, I have always been for video technology in the game.

    I understand FIFAs view about the cost, thats fine, so lets have it for the top divisions where the money is, and the important competitions like world cups!

    Sepp Blahblah says it will ruin the pace of the game.. ok, but we already have long stoppages if someone is suspected of bad behaviour, while the referee consults his officials. The 4th referee even, as you say, has a tv which he can check on and give the referee advice with. This can so so easily be used for goal line decisions. After all, its goals that make the game, lets get it right and get fair results. It doesn’t take long, and can even add to the spectacle while everyone waits for 10 seconds for the result of the video review.

    It works in cricket, and in rugby which isn’t exactly a game played at half pace either. Its just a shame that for England that the referee and linesman were the only people in the world to think the ball didn’t cross the line, and to think that Tevez opener was a legal goal against Mexico.

    Human error is part of the game, but I’d rather leave it to the players to make mistakes.

  • Dan

    0 0

    FIFA must start using video footage or other technological solutions for goal line decisons. It is unacceptable to have errors made on goal decisions when it can be so easily avoided. Join the Facebook group “Come on FIFA, use the video footage for crying out loud!”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This field is required *

Join the conversation!

or Register

Live Scores

advertisement

Betting Guide Advertisement

advertisement

Become a Writer
More More
Top