Tuesday, November 19, 2024

Is it time for the Premier League to re-join the real world?

Someone has to stop this

A while ago I wrote an article asking if the huge spending of Manchester City was right. I wondered if it was right for the sport and if it was right morally, particularly in the current economic plight. My conclusion was that I would think it was right if I was a Manchester City supporter, but almost nobody else would be able to happily support it.

Astonishing

Now the figures have been announced, they are even more astonishing than I thought they would be. Surely this has to be stopped doesn’t it?

The club have announced losses of £121 million for the twelve months leading up to 31st May this year. This figure is up from £92.5m for the previous year. It is one of the biggest losses ever in the Premier League, but to be fair to City, it isn’t the biggest. That dubious honour goes to Chelsea who lost £141 million in 2004-2005, the first full year under the ownership of Roman Abramovic.

Disturbing

The reason these figures are so disturbing is that the wage costs incurred by City are higher than the club’s entire turnover. Wage costs were £133 million and the turnover was £125 million. Put simply, that is ridiculous. No other businesses could be run like that.

City are owned by wealthy Sheikh Mansour of Abu Dhabi, who wants to see the club competing at the very top. He has spent more than £300 million on players since buying City in 2008. In a statement on the official club website he said,

Warmth

“Two years ago I was fortunate enough to become part of the Manchester City story and I remain grateful for the warmth of the welcome that you have given me. The ownership of a club like Manchester City, with such a rich heritage and diverse community of stakeholders, carries a unique set of obligations to the fans, staff and broader Manchester community. This is something I do not take lightly.

“Therefore the challenge I set my board and executive leadership team is to develop City so that it is one of the most successful clubs both on and off the pitch, but to do so without losing any of the characteristics that make it so special.”

He seems to have forgotten to mention that he is prepared to buy that success, whatever it costs!

Sustainable

On the plus side, City have increased their earnings considerably and have seen a massive rise in sponsorship. They are at pains to stress that they intend for their business to eventually become far more financially sustainable.

From next year, UEFA is set to introduce new financial fair play rulings with sanctions being applied if they are not met. Clubs will have three years to get the affairs in order One of the sanctions will be exclusion from European competitions. One of the rules will be that wage costs are kept to a manageable percentage of the overall turnover.

Crucial

All of a sudden, it has become even more crucial that Manchester City finish in the top four this season because unless there is a substantial turnaround in their balance sheet, this could be the last chance they get to qualify for Champions League football for some time.

I have to say that when you see small professional clubs going out of business with debts of £1 million or less, it is very difficult not to be outraged by the figures released by Manchester City. I have nothing against them as a club and I am sure that there are others who will release similar figures, if on a smaller scale, but I really do believe that enough is enough and the Premier League has to re-join the real world.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Graham Fisher


SHARE OR COMMENT ON THIS ARTICLE

WE RECOMMEND

  • Brad

    0 0

    soccer? What is soccer? This is football, shameless!!!

  • shameless

    0 0

    city are a good team n they dont want to start letting there fans down dnt start buying players just yet just keep playing soccer

  • Brad

    0 0

    they’ll lose any ole way. If you look at the red side of Manchester, you’ll see the success of developing home grown talent, and they haven’t kept losing as much as City.

  • Wale Silvers

    0 0

    You need to wake up to the realities of modern football. Madrid had spent so much in the past two years and are still spending. How can you now stop a team as ambitious as Man City not to spend? it is very certain that no team can qualify for Europe without having quality and depth. Can you purchase the required level of quality at chicken change price. or you will rather prefer City to wait for ten years and develop home grown talents (Arsenal style) and keep losing to stronger teams.

  • Blue Moony

    0 0

    How can it be wrong for someone to pump 100’s of millions of pounds of foreign investment into the premier league. This money is then distributed to other clubs via transfers at a time when the premier league would be taking a downward turn without it. Not only are they investing in our club, but they have pledged around a billion pounds into developing the area immediately around eastlands. This part of Manchester is desperately in need of this and I applaud the owners for their unrivalled generosity. Our owners haven’t come along and crippled the club with huge debts like United and Liverpool. They are the ones who are ruining the PL and reducing these 2 great clubs to bargain basement purchases.
    I think you should highlight the real threats to our league, Hicks & Gillette and the Glazier family.
    Your words are hollow and are probably driven by jealousy rather than any real concern for our league..
    Blue Moony

  • Blue Moony

    0 0

    How can it be wrong for someone to pump 100’s of millions of pounds of foreign investment into the premier league. This money is then distributed to other clubs via transfers at a time when the premier league would be taking a downward turn without it. Not only are they investing in our club, but they have pledged around a billion pounds into developing the area immediately around eastlands. This part of Manchester is desperately in need of this and I applaud the owners for their unrivalled generosity. Our owners haven’t come along and crippled the club with huge debts like United and Liverpool. They are the ones who are ruining the PL and reducing these 2 great clubs to bargain basement purchases.
    I think you should highlight the real threats to our league, Hicks & Gillette and the Glazier family.
    Your words are hollow and are probably driven by jealousy rather than any real concern for our league..
    Blue Moony

  • Wale Silvers

    0 0

    You need to wake up to the realities of modern football. Madrid had spent so much in the past two years and are still spending. How can you now stop a team as ambitious as Man City not to spend? it is very certain that no team can qualify for Europe without having quality and depth. Can you purchase the required level of quality at chicken change price. or you will rather prefer City to wait for ten years and develop home grown talents (Arsenal style) and keep losing to stronger teams.

  • Brad

    0 0

    they’ll lose any ole way. If you look at the red side of Manchester, you’ll see the success of developing home grown talent, and they haven’t kept losing as much as City.

  • shameless

    0 0

    city are a good team n they dont want to start letting there fans down dnt start buying players just yet just keep playing soccer

  • Brad

    0 0

    soccer? What is soccer? This is football, shameless!!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This field is required *

Join the conversation!

or Register

Live Scores

advertisement

Betting Guide Advertisement

advertisement

Become a Writer
More More
Top