Wednesday, November 20, 2024

Is James Milner really worth £30million?

Like everybody else I have been constantly hearing rumours linking Aston Villa midfielder James Milner with a move to Manchester City.

Today Villa boss Martin O’Neill has stated that the midfielder will be allowed to leave if the club receives a high enough offer.

Resigned

O’Neill told Sky Sports: “I had a conversation with James before the World Cup and he intimated that he’d like to go.

“City made an offer but it did not meet our valuation. I’m sure matters will be resolved soon. James is back next week having had an extended holiday.

“There is a difference of valuation at this moment between the buying club and the selling club. That may well be resolved and if that is the case then absolutely fine. I think James’ agent has told our chief executive that he wouldn’t be signing a new contract.

“Obviously that puts a different slant on things, like everything else. If a fee is agreed, at the end of the day, the player can leave.”

O’Neill is obviously resigned to losing the player and the player wants to go. Villa are believed to value Milner at £30million. I’m not so sure that Milner is worth the fee that Villa are asking for him.

Good

Don’t get me wrong I am a big fan of the England midfielder and believe he is a good player. He is only good and not world class. Can anyone really say that Milner is in the same league as David Villa?

The Spanish striker joined Barcelona for a similar fee earlier this summer. Villa has been a prolific striker in La Liga and has also become deadly in international football for his country. I know it’s hard to compare players from different positions but I know which one I would have signed if I had £30million.

Milner does have his qualities. He already has vast experience of the Premier League having played in the English top flight since making his debut as a 16 year-old for Leeds United. He has the ability to take on a man and put in a good cross and is also capable of striking the ball with tremendous power.

Milner has decided that he wishes to sign for Manchester City and challenge for trophies. From what I know about James Milner he isn’t just moving for the money. He is an ambitious lad and I’m sure he sees City as a team more likely to be successful than Villa in the near future.

Crazy

Manchester City have pushed up players values beyond their true worth. If Manchester City wasn’t interested in signing Milner would Villa really be asking £30million for the midfielder?

My answer is NO. I don’t blame Aston Villa as they don’t want to sell Milner because he is one of their key players. They can use some of the money to sign a replacement. In fact Villa could probably sign three good players to strengthen their squad with £30million.

Villa are just looking after themselves and they are right to ask Manchester City for a big fee. Everybody knows that Manchester City are rich beyond most clubs wildest dreams and will pay massively over the odds for players they want. It’s a simple case of supply and demand.

I can see Manchester City’s point of view as well as they want to sign the best players they possibly can and they have the funds to do so. Milner will be just one of the numerous major money signings this summer. Manchester City are playing fantasy football at the moment. What they need to remember is money doesn’t always buy you success but it will secure you the services of James Milner.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

David Nugent


David is a freelance football writer with nearly a decade of experience writing about the beautiful game. The experienced writer has written for over a dozen websites and also an international soccer magazine offline.
Arguably his best work has come as an editorial writer for Soccernews, sharing his good, bad and ugly opinions on the world’s favourite sport. During David’s writing career he has written editorials, betting previews, match previews, banter, news and opinion pieces.

SHARE OR COMMENT ON THIS ARTICLE

WE RECOMMEND

  • Pieter

    0 0

    There is no player in the world that is worth a 30 million pound transfer fee,its just sick.
    I like football but in the end it’s just a game and the social input to our everyday lifes is almost zero,it has no real importance at all.
    And the wages they get is absolutely crazy to.
    If you compare that to what a nurse,who is doing a far more important job gets than its even obscene and outrages

  • Chelsea FC Fan

    0 0

    @Dave…hell no – there is no comparison between Milner and Cesc. Milner is a good player, but Cesc…I don’t even have the words to explain Cesc’s talent…but he is far better, and will still continue to get better. I am sad to see him go and feel bad for Wenger and The Gunners.

    @kidssoccer…there is a distortion in the transfer market and that is not a true valuation of the player. There is no other club in this world that would even consider slightly entertaining that offer.

  • Chelsea FC Fan

    0 0

    England just didn’t represent the EPL style of play – nothing was fast, no intensity, no physical play – and I didn’t agree with Fabio’s selection either…Something is brewing internally among the squad…they need a new core, a new vision, new blood…the talent is all over the place – it’s just a matter of picking the pieces that work together and I really believe that we have two of the best midfielders in the world, Stevie G and Frankie Boy, that cannot play together in the same sand box.

  • Brad

    0 0

    one tournament doesnt prove anything. it just wasnt England’s year.

  • izvqc

    0 0

    This is really stupid! The whole bunch in England team is so overrated..and the WC proved this to be true!!!

  • Brad

    0 0

    I doubt if you could. Milner’s a fine player, but Cesc is far superior.

  • David Nugent

    0 0

    ChelseaFC, that is a good example. You can’t really even compare Cesc and Milner can you?

  • David Nugent

    0 0

    Kids Soccer, I actually mentioned the fact that Villa could buy three players with the fee in the article.

  • Kids Soccer

    0 0

    Milner is worth 30 million for the simple fact that City will pay the fee….I could probably buy 3 players for 30 million and all 3 would be better than Milner.

  • Shaka

    0 0

    It’s called business.It includes demand and supply.In this case,even though Milner is worth probally 10-12 million on a good season,only a club like city would pay that amount.If you want to know a player’s value,ask Arsene Wenger.He would give a thousand reasons why Milner is not worth that amount.

  • ChelseaFC Fan

    0 0

    haha…that’s hilarious…Milner for 30m?

    Dave – not sure why you didn’t use Cesc as an example, but Barca are looking to pay, what, 35m for him? Let me repeat that – BARCELONA VALUE CESC FABREGAS @ 35M (we know he’s worth more tho) – That’s only 5m more than Milner…haha…is Milner on Barca’s radar?

    Good for Villa tho – if they can manage to squeeze a 3000% profit out of this deal with City then i’d say it was a fair deal.

    The transfer market is out of control…

  • Sam

    0 0

    Well Villa are being clever coz they know city’s got a blank cheque. Get as much money out of them as possible. But yes David i agree with you that he probably won’t live up to the pricetag. Then again with the players city are buying, he’ll struggle to be in the first team

  • the_real_deal

    0 0

    it gets sicker by the day!

    Milner for 30 Million………… makes you wonder
    about the Valuer.

    it’s just crazy, CRAZY..

  • Dylan

    0 0

    they should be considered lucky if the get 22.5 million for him. he’s probably worth no more than 20 million max

  • Dylan

    0 0

    they should be considered lucky if the get 22.5 million for him. he’s probably worth no more than 20 million max

  • the_real_deal

    0 0

    it gets sicker by the day!

    Milner for 30 Million………… makes you wonder
    about the Valuer.

    it’s just crazy, CRAZY..

  • Sam

    0 0

    Well Villa are being clever coz they know city’s got a blank cheque. Get as much money out of them as possible. But yes David i agree with you that he probably won’t live up to the pricetag. Then again with the players city are buying, he’ll struggle to be in the first team

  • ChelseaFC Fan

    0 0

    haha…that’s hilarious…Milner for 30m?

    Dave – not sure why you didn’t use Cesc as an example, but Barca are looking to pay, what, 35m for him? Let me repeat that – BARCELONA VALUE CESC FABREGAS @ 35M (we know he’s worth more tho) – That’s only 5m more than Milner…haha…is Milner on Barca’s radar?

    Good for Villa tho – if they can manage to squeeze a 3000% profit out of this deal with City then i’d say it was a fair deal.

    The transfer market is out of control…

  • Shaka

    0 0

    It’s called business.It includes demand and supply.In this case,even though Milner is worth probally 10-12 million on a good season,only a club like city would pay that amount.If you want to know a player’s value,ask Arsene Wenger.He would give a thousand reasons why Milner is not worth that amount.

  • Kids Soccer

    0 0

    Milner is worth 30 million for the simple fact that City will pay the fee….I could probably buy 3 players for 30 million and all 3 would be better than Milner.

  • David Nugent

    0 0

    Kids Soccer, I actually mentioned the fact that Villa could buy three players with the fee in the article.

  • David Nugent

    0 0

    ChelseaFC, that is a good example. You can’t really even compare Cesc and Milner can you?

  • Brad

    0 0

    I doubt if you could. Milner’s a fine player, but Cesc is far superior.

  • izvqc

    0 0

    This is really stupid! The whole bunch in England team is so overrated..and the WC proved this to be true!!!

  • Brad

    0 0

    one tournament doesnt prove anything. it just wasnt England’s year.

  • Chelsea FC Fan

    0 0

    England just didn’t represent the EPL style of play – nothing was fast, no intensity, no physical play – and I didn’t agree with Fabio’s selection either…Something is brewing internally among the squad…they need a new core, a new vision, new blood…the talent is all over the place – it’s just a matter of picking the pieces that work together and I really believe that we have two of the best midfielders in the world, Stevie G and Frankie Boy, that cannot play together in the same sand box.

  • Chelsea FC Fan

    0 0

    @Dave…hell no – there is no comparison between Milner and Cesc. Milner is a good player, but Cesc…I don’t even have the words to explain Cesc’s talent…but he is far better, and will still continue to get better. I am sad to see him go and feel bad for Wenger and The Gunners.

    @kidssoccer…there is a distortion in the transfer market and that is not a true valuation of the player. There is no other club in this world that would even consider slightly entertaining that offer.

  • Pieter

    0 0

    There is no player in the world that is worth a 30 million pound transfer fee,its just sick.
    I like football but in the end it’s just a game and the social input to our everyday lifes is almost zero,it has no real importance at all.
    And the wages they get is absolutely crazy to.
    If you compare that to what a nurse,who is doing a far more important job gets than its even obscene and outrages

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This field is required *

Join the conversation!

or Register

Live Scores

advertisement

Betting Guide Advertisement

advertisement

Become a Writer
More More
Top