Sunday, December 22, 2024

Will Manchester United regret selling Ben Foster?

Birmingham City achieved a vital 1-0 victory over champions Chelsea today.

One of the main reasons for that victory was keeper Ben Foster’s man of the match performance.

He saved the Blues on numerous occasions against the league leaders and was on top form.

Heroic

The England international came to the rescue of Birmingham when they really needed a hero and performed heroics to deny Didier Drogba and co. He basically won the Blues the three very vital points.

Previous

At 27 Ben Foster still has a lot to prove to his critics. When he joined Manchester United from Stoke City in 2005 he was a promising young keeper. He couldn’t make the breakthrough into the first team.

United boss Alex Ferguson decided he wasn’t quite ready and sent him on-loan to Watford for two seasons. While at Vicarage Road he helped the Hornets to promotion to the Premier League and was fantastic between the posts.

When he returned to United he was expected to challenge for the number one shirt but unfortunately he endured a frustrating time at United due to injuries and lack of first team opportunities. He ended up making just twelve league appearances in his time at Old Trafford.

Switch

Due to the lack of first team football he decided to move on this summer and by all accounts has been in good form for Birmingham. The move worked out well for both Foster and for City.

City needed a keeper to replace Joe Hart, who had returned to Manchester City and Foster wanted regular first team football. He cost Birmingham £5million but could prove a real bargain.

Premature

With Manchester United now looking for a new keeper did Sir Alex Ferguson sell Foster at right time? Fergie knew that number one keeper Edwin Van Der Sar would be retiring soon and still decided to let Foster leave.

Ferguson must have thought that the keeper wasn’t reliable or good enough to be his first choice. Or maybe Foster just decided that he would never get the chance as the number one keeper at Old Trafford.

United are believed to be in negotiations with Norwegian side Aalesund over the £3.5million transfer of keeper Anders Lindegaard. Whether he will be the solution to Fergie’s problems remains to be seen but surely Foster would have been a good option for the United boss to have.

Another question would be is the 26 year-old Danish international better than Ben Foster? I couldn’t comment on the Danish star as I have never seen him play, however he must be good if Sir Alex is willing to make him his number one.

England

In recent years people have talked about a lack of reliable English goalkeepers. Yet Foster has always been talked about as a future England number one.

He has made just six appearances for the Three Lions but if he keeps playing consistently then he could push current England number one Joe Hart for the position. It will be good for England and good for the pair that they are competing for the position. It will stop them getting complacent and keep them on their toes.

Consistently

If Ben Foster can continue to perform consistently then he will have a good chance of establishing himself as a regular starter for club and country. After watching his performance against Chelsea United boss Sir Alex Ferguson must be asking himself if he made the right decision in selling Ben Foster.

Did Manchester United sell Ben Foster prematurely?

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

David Nugent


David is a freelance football writer with nearly a decade of experience writing about the beautiful game. The experienced writer has written for over a dozen websites and also an international soccer magazine offline.
Arguably his best work has come as an editorial writer for Soccernews, sharing his good, bad and ugly opinions on the world’s favourite sport. During David’s writing career he has written editorials, betting previews, match previews, banter, news and opinion pieces.

SHARE OR COMMENT ON THIS ARTICLE

WE RECOMMEND

  • the_real_deal

    0 0

    Most Utd fans wouldn’t be comfortable with Kuszcak and SFA should be careful with this department of the field.

    Our defence is less than impressive minus Ferdinand and Vidic, so we have to be cautious who we place between the posts.

  • Brad

    0 0

    Yeah Kuszcak is decent. Whether or not he’ll be able to take on the burden of being VDS’s successor is to be seen though.

  • ColdTurkey

    0 0

    Cameron you are perfectly right about kuzckack, Ive seen him play keeper for his previos club and he is magnificent, once he singlehandedly denied Wayne Rooney of scoring back in the day, Im going out on a limb by saying this, but I think he is the best one fit to have the No1 jersey after VDS is gone – He can be a real goalkeeping hero.

  • Cameron

    0 0

    And don’t forget about Tomasz Kuszczak. While he’s not a top class keeper, I certainly have complete faith in him between the posts if Edwin VDS gets injured.

  • Cameron

    0 0

    It’s a similar story to Tim Howard.

    Tim said he couldn’t handle the pressure at OT where every mistake was magnified.

    At Everton, he knew he’d still be no. 1 if he makes the odd mistake (a couple already this season), so it wouldn’t shake his confidence terribly.

  • Brad

    0 0

    He was very inconsistant and an epic fail during his time here, but who knows: maybe there’s a parallel universe where he stayed at Old Trafford and ended up being the new Gordon Banks and Lev Yashin put into one keeper.
    I’m not so sure. I think it was a little premature, as he’s doing so good now, but you have to look at his performances for us: crap.

  • ColdTurkey

    0 0

    Of course not they shouldn’t regret it, Ben Foster at Manchester United was very inconsistent and sometimes a flop, he got his chance at the beginnig of last season when Van Der Sar was out for a couple of months, and he proved to be not reliable (at Man Utd I stress), He made a lot of mistakes and a lot of bad judgements between the posts (not saying he didnt make a few saves). I think, Ben Foster’s transfer was just what he needed , it translated into a new clean slate for him, where he could rebuild his confidence, because he had little to non at old trafford, he was always nervous looking at old trafford. The bottom line is, the transfer was just right for him, and staying at Old trafford wouldnt have made him what he is now.

  • ColdTurkey

    0 0

    Of course not they shouldn’t regret it, Ben Foster at Manchester United was very inconsistent and sometimes a flop, he got his chance at the beginnig of last season when Van Der Sar was out for a couple of months, and he proved to be not reliable (at Man Utd I stress), He made a lot of mistakes and a lot of bad judgements between the posts (not saying he didnt make a few saves). I think, Ben Foster’s transfer was just what he needed , it translated into a new clean slate for him, where he could rebuild his confidence, because he had little to non at old trafford, he was always nervous looking at old trafford. The bottom line is, the transfer was just right for him, and staying at Old trafford wouldnt have made him what he is now.

  • Brad

    0 0

    He was very inconsistant and an epic fail during his time here, but who knows: maybe there’s a parallel universe where he stayed at Old Trafford and ended up being the new Gordon Banks and Lev Yashin put into one keeper.
    I’m not so sure. I think it was a little premature, as he’s doing so good now, but you have to look at his performances for us: crap.

  • Cameron

    0 0

    It’s a similar story to Tim Howard.

    Tim said he couldn’t handle the pressure at OT where every mistake was magnified.

    At Everton, he knew he’d still be no. 1 if he makes the odd mistake (a couple already this season), so it wouldn’t shake his confidence terribly.

  • Cameron

    0 0

    And don’t forget about Tomasz Kuszczak. While he’s not a top class keeper, I certainly have complete faith in him between the posts if Edwin VDS gets injured.

  • ColdTurkey

    0 0

    Cameron you are perfectly right about kuzckack, Ive seen him play keeper for his previos club and he is magnificent, once he singlehandedly denied Wayne Rooney of scoring back in the day, Im going out on a limb by saying this, but I think he is the best one fit to have the No1 jersey after VDS is gone – He can be a real goalkeeping hero.

  • Brad

    0 0

    Yeah Kuszcak is decent. Whether or not he’ll be able to take on the burden of being VDS’s successor is to be seen though.

  • the_real_deal

    0 0

    Most Utd fans wouldn’t be comfortable with Kuszcak and SFA should be careful with this department of the field.

    Our defence is less than impressive minus Ferdinand and Vidic, so we have to be cautious who we place between the posts.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This field is required *

Join the conversation!

or Register

Live Scores

advertisement

Betting Guide Advertisement

advertisement

Become a Writer
More More
Top